"To live as a god not subject to any rules, you end up living as a monster." Lack of empathy, even from the clergy. It has a name, and it isn't "Ivan".
Looks like the quality of leadership from those in power all comes down to personal morality and ethics. Or the lack thereof. Assuming they have at least competence in their chosen field.
Which seems to rule out almost everyone of note in the current presidential administration, where corruption and immorality are considered virtues.
At work, I am respected, people listen to me, I am well compensated, and I mostly decide how I spend my time. I stride through hallways confidently. At home, nobody cares. I'm just dad/husband. Respected, sure, but also laughed at and blamed for things. I usually don't take it personally since I know, that's just how it is.
Unlike what you did, many people in your situation would find a way to work more and more, dinners with clients, big deals, and thus avoid the unpleasantness and potential failures of home life. I remember you wrote that you were home for dinner often, which is a testament to your determination to not fall into that trap.
There is a phrase in performance psychology - True mastery is doing two opposite things at once. Here I am just trying to live my best life!
Thanks Sanjay for the comment. When they laugh at you, you know they feel confident in your love. That's what i'ver been telling myself for a long time now, and I think it's true.
Very insightful analysis, David. This ties in with the tech bros’ promise that their tech, especially AI, will give us all a frictionless life. Frictionless is their holy grail, so they assume it should be ours as well. In the friction, the struggle, lies meaning and growth. They’re missing the entire point and it’s killing us — and our planet.
Thank you David. I’m clearly not a member of the ultra wealthy, but I’ve certainly been self-centered at times and put out by what are essentially minor inconveniences (when the world has too much real suffering). Reading today’s piece made me think of Michael Jackson’s “Man in the Mirror.” I need to work on myself.
I was in the midst of this post when my elderly mother in law called me because her smoke alarm is beeping. She can’t climb a ladder, and lives far enough away that this will take over my one stretch of personal time this weekend. Friction! My wife agreed to salute me as a hero (at my insistence) so that’s a big payoff. Friction! Then I finished reading. I’ll keep Ivan Ilyich in mind while I drive 45 minutes each way. (And while you’re out, the groceries?)
I appreciated your reflections about the role of encountering friction in developing personal character, and in making important memories with other people. I hope to have the courage and humility to bring relationships and their frictions into my little life.
Thank you, also, for the description about the Nanosaur game in the footnote. It sounds like it was a fun game for you and your son.
Rosebud. Remember Citizen Kane? These stories and themes are constant reminders to us all. For us non-oligarchs the message is don’t fret over first world problems. I’m happiest when with my family, volunteering, helping out.
I’m surprised an Atlantic writer was invited to Campfire. Did Bezos know he would write about the experience?
BTW Musk’s awkward way of showing heartfelt thanks to an applauding audience was not a Nazi salute.
I don't believe the author is an Atlantic employee. I read the article a while ago, but I believe Bezos (or someone on his team) discovered his writing elsewhere, and the author himself was surprised at the invite. They decided to go because, why not?
Re: Musk, if it wasn't a Nazi salute, it certainly was taken that way by other Nazis. And Elon's anti Semitism has shown itself in other ways.
Agree. He’s an interesting animal for sure, but I think he has good intentions and I don’t think he and Bezos are alike in the “frictionless” discussion. I think Elon thrives on it…
Hawley is a well regarded and successful author and if he'd only done the Fargo TV series, he'd have done quite a lot. He says in the article that he'd turned down a production deal with Amazon and suspects that maybe that led to the invitation.
Good point about Tolstoy's valorizing farming and the peasant lifestyle of his time. The most favorable character in Ivan Ilyich is his peasant servant Gerosim. That said, Tolstoy did not portray favorably the people a few rungs down who tried to imitate aristocracy. Thanks Jennifer for the comment.
Great piece David. I’ve had customers in my life that noticeably abhorred friction in their lives to the point that it caused friction. They thought they were clever enough to get ahead of it by firing someone before they needed to. It was explained that this saved all the trouble, in other words friction, of poor performance that would lead to firing.
They always ended up paying for it with their peace. Crazy stuff.
Tolstoy was himself a wealthy man who abandoned his wealth and his profession at the end of his life because he felt that had not lived up to the moral standards he set for himself and others. Whereas Bezos has only abandoned his humility and sympathy for other people.
Along those same lines, Nabokov in his lectures on Russian literature describes Tolstoy as thinking his two great novels––AK and W&P––were "sins" he had to make up for. I guess because they did not deal primarily with spiritual matters. thanks David for the comment.
You may be right about Bezos, but I think Musk got to be 8-years old and adopted some kind of sci-fi/superhero concept of self. It even includes going to Mars. His wealth has allowed him to live an outsized life which is only reinforced this outsized self-concept. I think this role is so comfortable that he will never abandon it.
You brought Ivan to the story! And Tolstoy deep thoughts! This is true that work might be easier than family relationships. It has more defined rules . But I just lost my father and I think differently about life. It’s only a wheel and different lessons. Most likely Besos need that lesson and you need your Nanozaur! Bravo!
These days my focus is on becoming a more mindful and observant parent. I remind myself friction can be a good thing - often it can be a sign to re-engage with our son using a different approach. Much depends on one's mindset.
"To live as a god not subject to any rules, you end up living as a monster." Lack of empathy, even from the clergy. It has a name, and it isn't "Ivan".
Looks like the quality of leadership from those in power all comes down to personal morality and ethics. Or the lack thereof. Assuming they have at least competence in their chosen field.
Which seems to rule out almost everyone of note in the current presidential administration, where corruption and immorality are considered virtues.
this one resonated with me. Thanks Dave.
At work, I am respected, people listen to me, I am well compensated, and I mostly decide how I spend my time. I stride through hallways confidently. At home, nobody cares. I'm just dad/husband. Respected, sure, but also laughed at and blamed for things. I usually don't take it personally since I know, that's just how it is.
Unlike what you did, many people in your situation would find a way to work more and more, dinners with clients, big deals, and thus avoid the unpleasantness and potential failures of home life. I remember you wrote that you were home for dinner often, which is a testament to your determination to not fall into that trap.
There is a phrase in performance psychology - True mastery is doing two opposite things at once. Here I am just trying to live my best life!
Great comment. This is another reason why having kids is a blessing. It’s humbling.
Or grounding, a reality check.
Thanks Sanjay for the comment. When they laugh at you, you know they feel confident in your love. That's what i'ver been telling myself for a long time now, and I think it's true.
Coincidentally I am reading Ivan Ilyich right now. I am down to the last pages. It’s a poignant read. And a great cautionary tale.
Thanks Gail.
Very insightful analysis, David. This ties in with the tech bros’ promise that their tech, especially AI, will give us all a frictionless life. Frictionless is their holy grail, so they assume it should be ours as well. In the friction, the struggle, lies meaning and growth. They’re missing the entire point and it’s killing us — and our planet.
I do think they'r missing the point and are more slaves than overlords in some senses.
Thank you David. I’m clearly not a member of the ultra wealthy, but I’ve certainly been self-centered at times and put out by what are essentially minor inconveniences (when the world has too much real suffering). Reading today’s piece made me think of Michael Jackson’s “Man in the Mirror.” I need to work on myself.
I was in the midst of this post when my elderly mother in law called me because her smoke alarm is beeping. She can’t climb a ladder, and lives far enough away that this will take over my one stretch of personal time this weekend. Friction! My wife agreed to salute me as a hero (at my insistence) so that’s a big payoff. Friction! Then I finished reading. I’ll keep Ivan Ilyich in mind while I drive 45 minutes each way. (And while you’re out, the groceries?)
Perfect, Zargon, and you made me laugh.
Crisis resolved. Plus great jazz on the car radio on the way over.
You're blessed to have a mother in law.
I appreciated your reflections about the role of encountering friction in developing personal character, and in making important memories with other people. I hope to have the courage and humility to bring relationships and their frictions into my little life.
Thank you, also, for the description about the Nanosaur game in the footnote. It sounds like it was a fun game for you and your son.
Thanks Sarah. I never did get through knack for Nanosaur! Spatially challenged.
Rosebud. Remember Citizen Kane? These stories and themes are constant reminders to us all. For us non-oligarchs the message is don’t fret over first world problems. I’m happiest when with my family, volunteering, helping out.
I’m surprised an Atlantic writer was invited to Campfire. Did Bezos know he would write about the experience?
BTW Musk’s awkward way of showing heartfelt thanks to an applauding audience was not a Nazi salute.
I don't believe the author is an Atlantic employee. I read the article a while ago, but I believe Bezos (or someone on his team) discovered his writing elsewhere, and the author himself was surprised at the invite. They decided to go because, why not?
Re: Musk, if it wasn't a Nazi salute, it certainly was taken that way by other Nazis. And Elon's anti Semitism has shown itself in other ways.
Respectfully disagree. Musk visited Israel after Oct 7 and wore the Bring Them Home dog tag until the hostages were freed.
Only after he was called out for endorsing an antisemitic conspiracy.
https://www.cnn.com/2023/11/17/business/elon-musk-reveals-his-actual-truth
He’s not a reliable friend.
I agree. Not sure why so many Liberals try to paint Musk as an anti semite
Agree. He’s an interesting animal for sure, but I think he has good intentions and I don’t think he and Bezos are alike in the “frictionless” discussion. I think Elon thrives on it…
Hawley is a well regarded and successful author and if he'd only done the Fargo TV series, he'd have done quite a lot. He says in the article that he'd turned down a production deal with Amazon and suspects that maybe that led to the invitation.
By the way I had Kane and Rosebud in an earlier draft. Very much on point.
That's a wonderful story about the Nanosaur! I am, to this day, completely incapable of playing a video game, so it's particularly humorous to me.
I never thought of Tolstoy as a snob.. I think of his rapturous descriptions of farm life and field work and how he turned to menial work as a balm...
Good point about Tolstoy's valorizing farming and the peasant lifestyle of his time. The most favorable character in Ivan Ilyich is his peasant servant Gerosim. That said, Tolstoy did not portray favorably the people a few rungs down who tried to imitate aristocracy. Thanks Jennifer for the comment.
Great piece David. I’ve had customers in my life that noticeably abhorred friction in their lives to the point that it caused friction. They thought they were clever enough to get ahead of it by firing someone before they needed to. It was explained that this saved all the trouble, in other words friction, of poor performance that would lead to firing.
They always ended up paying for it with their peace. Crazy stuff.
Yes, there can be more friction in avoiding friction! Thanks John.
Really great and insightful article, thank you! Hadn't heard of the Ivan story before definitely worth pondering more about.
Thanks Kat. Ivan Ilyich is a short and fascinating read and well worth it.
Tolstoy was himself a wealthy man who abandoned his wealth and his profession at the end of his life because he felt that had not lived up to the moral standards he set for himself and others. Whereas Bezos has only abandoned his humility and sympathy for other people.
Along those same lines, Nabokov in his lectures on Russian literature describes Tolstoy as thinking his two great novels––AK and W&P––were "sins" he had to make up for. I guess because they did not deal primarily with spiritual matters. thanks David for the comment.
I love your writing, introspection, and big heart!!!
You may be right about Bezos, but I think Musk got to be 8-years old and adopted some kind of sci-fi/superhero concept of self. It even includes going to Mars. His wealth has allowed him to live an outsized life which is only reinforced this outsized self-concept. I think this role is so comfortable that he will never abandon it.
Kathleen, I think you're probably right about Musk.
You brought Ivan to the story! And Tolstoy deep thoughts! This is true that work might be easier than family relationships. It has more defined rules . But I just lost my father and I think differently about life. It’s only a wheel and different lessons. Most likely Besos need that lesson and you need your Nanozaur! Bravo!
Thanks Maria.
These days my focus is on becoming a more mindful and observant parent. I remind myself friction can be a good thing - often it can be a sign to re-engage with our son using a different approach. Much depends on one's mindset.
Thanks for the comment, Molly.
Good piece. Equally applicable to women as men. I was certainly aware of the differences between work and home back when I was working.