148 Comments
User's avatar
User's avatar
Comment removed
Mar 2, 2024
Comment removed
Expand full comment
David Roberts's avatar

Thanks Isabel.

Expand full comment
Camila Hamel's avatar

Happy birthday!

Expand full comment
Leah Martin-Dagher's avatar

At age 60 on my birthday I was asked how does it feel? My response: "Pretty good, considering that I have died a few times. "

Expand full comment
Mcdude's avatar

Happy Birthday! That looks like a Checker cab? Have you ever watched “Best Years of Our Lives”? Love your writing.

Expand full comment
Etta Madden's avatar

You’re helping me anticipate my 62nd birthday exactly one month from now! (And, I met my husband in 1984. We still have our early correspondence, but it’s boxed up in the attic. And, he rarely reads anything I write.) But back to the subject—about 6 years ago I started interviewing people to discuss their “later vocations.” The phrase ended up in my book that came out in 2022–all about 19th-century women finding new callings after mid-life. The contemporary interviews never went beyond two blog posts. I had too much going on back then to take it further. Of course, with both projects I was working through my own desires to open new paths…. I am still working on that! I am definitely not dreading my birthday!

Expand full comment
David Roberts's avatar

Thanks for the comment, Etta. What's the name of your book?

And early Happy Birthday!

Expand full comment
Etta Madden's avatar

Thank you, David! The book is an academic one, footnotes & all: Engaging Italy: American Women's Utopian Visions and Transnational Networks (SUNY P -- running a 30% off sale this month!). The "utopian visions" phrase emphasizes the way these women followed new dreams at mid-life. Your writing is making me want to dig back into the interviews with contemporary friends (men and women) who impress me with their abilities to follow new open doors or make new paths for themselves. Keep it up!

Expand full comment
Gillian Culff's avatar

I am so interested in how women find new directions after some sort of big transition like divorce, menopause, the empty nest, or some combination of the above.

Expand full comment
Etta Madden's avatar

Thank you, Gillian! I started a response to you and it somehow got eating in cyberspace! Anyway, You can see from my comment to David more about my book (and also here: https://sunypress.edu/Books/E/Engaging-Italy) . But you might really like @Anneboydrioux 's substack -- was Letters from Anne but is now Audacious Women, Creative Lives.

Expand full comment
Gillian Culff's avatar

Thanks for the recommendation! I had asked your book's title, but when I saw your reply to David, I thought perhaps I just hadn't seen it and deleted my comment. Then I realized you had only just replied to him, so I left a new comment! That's probably what happened to your response to me--it vanished when I deleted my question about the book. In any case, thank you!

Expand full comment
Wendy Schwarz's avatar

Happy Birthday David!

Expand full comment
Laura's avatar

Simply beautiful - and oh so vulnerable and true. Bravo for having the courage to question youthful expectations of how to show up in the world and discovering you have so much more to give and do. Your birthday gift of realization and joy is actually a gift to the world!

Expand full comment
David Roberts's avatar

Thanks Laura!

Expand full comment
Thaissa Lara's avatar

-- Firstly, happy, happy birthday, David. I always believed that there’s an exquisite power in being alive in one’s sixties. I wonder if it feels that different from my current 32. And yes, there’s time too – that entity or energy that never ceases to leave its message, whether we are ready or not. Great essay. Xo.

Expand full comment
David Roberts's avatar

Thaissa, thanks for the comment. When i read many of the Substack essays of people in their 30s, like you, I marvel at how advanced you all are in your self-awareness and questioning compared to my memory of being that age. I really think it's the writing.

Expand full comment
Su Terry's avatar

I have that same experience....liking to think I was as self aware as they seem to be.....but in reality I was pretty clueless. BTW if you think 62 was a trip, wait till you get to....uh.....64.

Expand full comment
David Spinks's avatar

I’ve fallen into the trap of believing that in order to practice my love of writing, it has to be tied to something else I love, and choose to write about. This gave me hope that, just maybe, writing can be enough.

Appreciated this post a great deal.

And after reading your card, I’ve realized there’s much more room for creative writing in the cards I send to my loved ones. That was beautiful.

Expand full comment
David Roberts's avatar

Thanks David.

Expand full comment
June Girvin's avatar

Happy Birthday! I greet my birthdays with neither great joy nor great dread. I'm thankful for another alive in this essentially beautiful world.

Expand full comment
Gillian Culff's avatar

I share your gratitude for another year. I can think of many friends and family members who never made it to whatever age I happen to be. I'm glad for each year, and I do my best to make the most of it.

Expand full comment
Good Humor by CK Steefel's avatar

Same. In fact I thank G-d every morning when I wake up. 🥰🙏

Expand full comment
Natasha Deckmann's avatar

Happy Birthday! I gave you a tennis win as your gift! ;)

I love the taxi card, so sweet.

Expand full comment
David Roberts's avatar

Sounds like a challenge for a rematch!

Expand full comment
Rona Maynard's avatar

Happy birthday, David. I wish you many years to love those dear to you while pursuing this consumingly odd and (to me, anyway) intermittingly thrilling vocation. Writing doesn’t make a lot of sense to those who are not writers. The tangible rewards are elusive and few. Yet when you know you’ve said what you didn’t even know you meant, and in the saying made a difference to even one reader, writing is flying. Does a tax lawyer know this feeling? Or a dentist? Later life is the best time to write. You have more to say than you imagined possible when younger, and no expectations to be a wunderkind.

Expand full comment
David Roberts's avatar

Thanks Rona. I agree with that perspective. Although I have been surprised at how many young writers on Substack seem to be precocious in their self-awareness. Which I think is due to the fact that they write.

Expand full comment
Maria Mayer Feng's avatar

Happy belated birthday. I love this article.

As a long time journal writer ( since I am 13) I only recently came to understand why I am doing it. I first did it because I wanted to document my life, so I’ll remember it later. But turns out the information I wrote down became so irrelevant for the future. (Who cares how cool Kim Wilde is now!) the slow speed of handwriting is just there to help me slow down to think. It almost doesn’t matter what I write. Because I have no audience. : )

Expand full comment
David Roberts's avatar

Thanks Maria. I suspect you recognize the book from which the taxi picture was taken!

Expand full comment
Maria Mayer Feng's avatar

Of course! : )

Expand full comment
Matthew Long's avatar

David - You were one of the first writers I subscribed to when I joined Substack. Reading your words over the past four months and watching you find your voice and passion in this place has been a blessing. You were also one of my very first paid subscribers, and that act of kindness on your part did so much to encourage me to continue writing when I felt so out of place. I am delighted you are here, sharing your voice and journey with the world. I always look forward to your articles showing up in my inbox. Happy birthday, and I look forward to benefiting from your vocation in the years ahead.

Expand full comment
David Roberts's avatar

Thanks Matthew and I am equally happy to be part of your community and to be able to enjoy your writing.

Expand full comment
Debbie Weil's avatar

David, HB! I love the card and inscription to your wife and a big THANKS to her for prompting (prodding) you to write. 62 is nice but I have to say that 72 (where I am now) is even better in terms of self awareness. Even if the reflection in the mirror is a bit less appealing. Excited to be writing with you and grateful for your support.

Expand full comment
David Roberts's avatar

Thanks Debbie and looking forward to learning more from you about 72.

Expand full comment
Ann Richardson's avatar

And if I dare to say so, 82 is even better!

Expand full comment
Debbie Weil's avatar

maybe there’s a -2’s club

Expand full comment
Ann Richardson's avatar

Yup.

Expand full comment
Tara Penry's avatar

Happy birthday, David. This line stood out powerfully to me - so succinct, matter of fact, and full of awareness: “I realized I had needlessly enslaved myself to the mythologies of my youth.” I’m glad to be part of your Substack community. Adding a little breath of gratitude to your pile of birthday wishes.

Expand full comment
David Roberts's avatar

Thanks Tara.

Expand full comment
Richard Moody's avatar

Your comments about dear old Frodo are so true. Aren’t these the same sentiments “you can’t go back” many people feel when life has performed one of its upheavals. I think for example of the veterans, who find returning to civilian life so daunting. They think other people don’t understand, and I for one certainly can’t understand.

On a more mundane note. It’s also my grandson’s birthday today. He’s eight. . We bought him a football game, or a football shirt, or a pair of goalies gloves, or something like that. You get the drift. March birthdays are good - right at the beginning of Spring, full of hope.

It’s even sunny here in Banstead today. Daffodils are out.

And I’ve just subscribed to your site. Thanks.

Expand full comment
David Roberts's avatar

Hi Richard,

Thanks for the comment.

I just looked up Banstead on Google. The pictures are beautiful!

Enjoy the sunny day and happy birthday to your grandson.

Expand full comment