I met Jim Downey at a dinner last summer and mentioned the change bank sketch. He was surprised someone knew he’d written it, and I explained I was a comedy nerd. He couldn’t have been nicer and friendlier.
One thing about ANT is you could see it as a giant wealth transfer to a couple of hundred employees and pre-IPO investors from millions of workers who will be made redundant by Claude AI and shareholders in other companies, like software ones, the future reallocation of profits from which is meant to justify ANT’s current valuation. This is not a win-win situation.
I've been saying for a decade that one day they are going to flip that switch JUST FOR FUN and watch us all moiling around in confusion like a stirred up ANTS nest. I hope I'm at home when they do.
While the People With the Money (Capitalists) are focusing on all the incredible potential profits in biotech, materials science, vibecoding, etc.; the People With The Guns (Militiaries, Spy Agencies) are focusing on the new ways to kill adversaries. With designer plagues, autonomous drones, precision point defense gunnery, and best of all: rogue AI's that can massively crash power grids, computer networks, and create industrial accidents.
It's these Natsec applications we should be truly worried about. Because an AGI programmed to cause mass casualty incidents can--and likely will--turn on its creator.
As manufacturing--and every other facet of industrial production--becomes increasingly automated, and anthropomorphic robot soldiers, police, workers, etc. become more sophisticated and effective, the time will come when AGI's already programmed to disregard human life will see humankind as no longer necessary to their survival.
The US military have been doing research for decades on “ enhanced” human bodies. That 1970s show The Six Milion Dollar Man,and later Woman ( loved Lindsey Wagner) didn't come out of nowhere. But much more frightening in my opinion is that they have established that the most successful form of automated and autonomous killing device is tiny but en masse. Imagine a swarm of (OMG I feel ill) spider like and sized Things coming toward you. They are many and programmed to overwhelm you by sheer mass. I hate writing or thinking about this but I've read of it and I can see it would be effective. On the battle front or in besieged cities against civilian population.
Mr Roberts. As an in my early 20s person with a total shitshow life I was IN LOVE WITH HER ,totally. And I still think she is one of those few people at the top of evolution. But my love was in no way Lezzie. I hate how since from the 1960s the word love has got inextricably entangled with the word and concept of sex. Contrived thus of course. I think you can passionately love a person but it doesn't entail…oh well it's a deep hole I'm sure you know what I mean. This lady always seemed to me MORE than an actor,like a MEANINGFUL PERSON . And I know she left acting and went into teaching and human rights. I dont know if she is still with us but I think she was a fine person.
Yes. I hear speculation on how a blip on our device can kill us. I was puzzled at first. But as you say,it's the command the blip can send to shut down an operating system that will do it.
Your posts always teach me something David, as learning is so important to my every day existence. Sometimes though, I feel so uneducated and / or ignorant reading them (entirely not your fault BTW)!!
Reading this one through attracted me as I was eager to understand who exactly was the AI company that my husband had vaguely heard about overnight on his constant BBC World Service radio stream into his half awake ears and mind and as I don't watch the News. And then to hear your views. But you sadly lost me in the second sentence with "IPO" which Safari helped me with. (Good job telling me what ANT was!! :) and thank you as always for the great footnotes.
When I used to lecture in engineering or speak at conferences, I was always told not use acronyms or initialisms unless I explained them first. I was shocked that even though we were very minor 'traders' in stocks and shares back in the day; I had never heard of IPO but had clearly participated in them many times. Then you termed yourself as 'OG' further on and I assumed 'Old Guy'? Sorry. 🫣 Safari though, said it stands for "original gangster", or someone or something that is an originator, authentic, or highly respected for experience and seniority. I will remember you as this now.
As always, I go off track and have to say I think this piece is really interesting, very informative and certainly valuable for those hearing this on the News, or not! And.......I agree with your first internet search that you listed, what are the rules in the UK indeed?! And I love that you watch Blue Lights too!!
Thanks Sally. I should have spelled out the acronym for IPO, although I’m not sure I’d ever style myself as a “gangster!” So I hid behind that acronym.
I'm a UK citizen who lives here and most of us are asking what the rules are now,if there are any. We just get our Prime Ministers appointed,by each other and our King is off with the fairies
I to am a UK citizen Jane but now living in Spain and wondering what’s going on from afar and when you have children and grandchildren back there it can all be very disconcerting. That’s if we take any notice of what the media says too!!
I watched the SNL sketch twice and just could not stop laughing. So dry. Many thanks for making my day. Also thank you for sharing your thoughts on AI.
You sound like my husband, less worried about AI than me. My husband’s portfolio is probably majority tech while mine is more diverse. I’m kind of on the fence about AI being oversaturated and becoming the next dot com. Yet I still bought a small number of ANT on its debut day.
Cynthia, it will be fascinating to watch it unfold. Public opinion is so negative on AI companies that any serious damage to people, e.g., an AI turning off electricity in the winter, will bring about huge political repercussions to these companies. So, I see politics as a tripwire.
I do feel encouraged that you do not fear AI will render humans obsolete and jobless. Or that AI will be able to create artificial birth babies that grow up into fautless adults that perfectly impersonate perfect humans who gradually replace imperfect humans who are alive and would retain the living volition and agency that the AI babies wouldn't have until programmed with. Existence will finally become orderly because there will be no more variables leading to either bad manners or nuclear war. I stlll don't understand how all the negative possibilities of AI can be avoided. But if you believe they can or that they won't render humans extinct, that is comforting. Anything you might add concerning this would be great to read. But I think you must have good reasons for not being worried.
Public opinion is so negative on AI companies that any serious damage to people, e.g., an AI turning off electricity in the winter, will bring about huge political repercussions to these companies. So, I see politics as a tripwire.
This is a good, measured view. My industry is being a bit too precious about it, but internally, some big publishers are using AI — and so much is already AI-powered (like metadata). Then there are publishers who will let AI-assisted writing slide because they know the book will sell.
It's not good to be an absolutist about AI, because it is here to stay.
CNBC and other outlets suggested for days that the IPO was going to be a "clearing event." That is an event that will send, hopefully, a positive signal about the financial market's ability to efficiently allocate capital. I suspect the outlets were simply trying to appeal to the average investor's desire to see the market less as a casino but more as a efficient price discovery mechanism. Your piece nicely points out how various forces, most notably uncertainty, are driving trading and how the term "clearing event" was a bit misused. Again, thanks for the thoughtful piece.
Great point about Anthropic showing up in ETFs so more people can enjoy the benefit. 🙏🏻
When hubby told me about all the instant millionaires who work at Anthropic I was thrilled for them.
Finally, I love the story about Ashton Kutcher and Mila Kunis. Mila did not like him investing in Uber, which made him a fortune. Then she didn’t want him to invest $400 million into Anthropic. Now they’re worth 7 billion and Mila should stick to acting. 😂😂
The Proust query in your list made me smile, because that is exactly the sort of question I would never trust my own memory on and would still feel faintly guilty asking a machine. The revenues point lands too. A company can be growing fast and still be a long way from the part that matters, which is whether the money stays after the bills are paid. Do you think the market is mostly pricing the hope that the bills shrink, or that the revenue keeps compounding faster than anyone expects?
I think it is fear of missing out on what could turn into the most valuable company ever. Of course so many things have to go right for that to happen. The hype is huge but that doesn't mean it isn't right.
I don't understand ANY OF THIS which of course is why I'm who I am with my life. I'm not so upbeat as yourself Mr Roberts of the potential benefits of AI but yes,I dont think it's the dire threat to human life it's painted as either. It's notable that the people who are TALKING IT UP as dangerous,formidable,scary etc are the very people supposedly making it and selling it ,they obviously know or have been advised that making something sound dark and dangerous and forbidding (or even forbidden) is a winning sales pitch. - see I do know some stuff! Our Mrs Thatcher broke union power by selling off our industries and facilities. Her idea was that everyone should buy a few shares in phones,water,gas etc but it doesnt work like that as you know Mr Roberts. Everyone owning say,ten shares in the local water company and hiding them under the mattress for 30 years will result in worthless bits of paper nibbled by mice! Lots of people bought those 10 shares then sold them within hours for a huge profit to the big investors and everyone had http://to.do it pronto as by next day the market had collapsed. So in about 24 hours the nationalised industries and companies went from the peoples hands straight back into monolithic ownership. Good or Bad I don't know really. Water comes out of my taps and trains get me places. I don't really care otherwise.
Hi David, I read the same article in the WSJ and had to read the part about revenue growth twice since the writer referenced revenue growth as a positive indicator for Anthropic without considering future earnings potential or lack thereof. I thought I had misread that section of the article the first time. I really enjoyed your piece today. Hope all is well.
Two things. First, most people forget that, for many years, Amazon lost money and still loses money in the book business. But investors bought in at ridiculous levels on the prospect of future growth and earnings in other segments. In this case, their vision was rewarded, although in others, their futures bets went bust. Kind of like horse race handicapping...
As to AI, the sad truth is that no one has any real idea of the societal impact because this is most profound technological change in human history...makes printing with moveable type seem insignificant. Given short shrift is the very real potential of AI, especially when combined with robotics, to displace huge segments of the working population, leaving them little recourse to find other employment. In addition, we humans keep poisoning our environment, irrelevant to robots, which need neither food, water, nor clean air. It is thus not impossible that at some point in the not too distant future, computers might say to humans, "What do we need you for?" (I actually wrote that in a novel published thirty years ago.)
It seems that our only alternative is to move more slowly and more carefully, building in the sort of checks and controls that renders doomsday scenarios moot. But hey. that might have knocked Anthropic's market value down to $1 trillion. Oh, the horror.
I think the politics have turned so negative against the AI companies that any mishap that causes real damage to people will set off a political tripwire. And I think that a mishap is likely to occur before a robotic-led extermination. I’m thinking of something like a disruption to power.
"Sam’s trip to Vermont to visit a cult posing as a monastery. The cult claims to be creating a solution to the evils of AI through recording their quiet meditations and prayers."
More proof, if any were needed, that the well of human absurdity will never run dry.
LLMs remind me of the old Judaic Tanaaim—the professional memorizers. They never forget a detail about Proust.
From Google AI: Living Tape Recorders: Because Jewish law prohibited writing down the Oral Torah at the time, these men served as a living archive. They possessed exceptional mnemonic skills and committed massive volumes of rabbinic legal traditions (Mishnayot and Baraitot) to memory.
I met Jim Downey at a dinner last summer and mentioned the change bank sketch. He was surprised someone knew he’d written it, and I explained I was a comedy nerd. He couldn’t have been nicer and friendlier.
Good to know.
Trivia. No one in the cast could get the tone exactly right, so Downey, who was just a writer, had to play the banker himself.
He did a great job!
I loved that sketch when I first saw it.
One thing about ANT is you could see it as a giant wealth transfer to a couple of hundred employees and pre-IPO investors from millions of workers who will be made redundant by Claude AI and shareholders in other companies, like software ones, the future reallocation of profits from which is meant to justify ANT’s current valuation. This is not a win-win situation.
It will be fascinating to watch what happens.
I've been saying for a decade that one day they are going to flip that switch JUST FOR FUN and watch us all moiling around in confusion like a stirred up ANTS nest. I hope I'm at home when they do.
While the People With the Money (Capitalists) are focusing on all the incredible potential profits in biotech, materials science, vibecoding, etc.; the People With The Guns (Militiaries, Spy Agencies) are focusing on the new ways to kill adversaries. With designer plagues, autonomous drones, precision point defense gunnery, and best of all: rogue AI's that can massively crash power grids, computer networks, and create industrial accidents.
It's these Natsec applications we should be truly worried about. Because an AGI programmed to cause mass casualty incidents can--and likely will--turn on its creator.
As manufacturing--and every other facet of industrial production--becomes increasingly automated, and anthropomorphic robot soldiers, police, workers, etc. become more sophisticated and effective, the time will come when AGI's already programmed to disregard human life will see humankind as no longer necessary to their survival.
I hope and think you’re wrong about killer robots who will extinguish humanity.
The US military have been doing research for decades on “ enhanced” human bodies. That 1970s show The Six Milion Dollar Man,and later Woman ( loved Lindsey Wagner) didn't come out of nowhere. But much more frightening in my opinion is that they have established that the most successful form of automated and autonomous killing device is tiny but en masse. Imagine a swarm of (OMG I feel ill) spider like and sized Things coming toward you. They are many and programmed to overwhelm you by sheer mass. I hate writing or thinking about this but I've read of it and I can see it would be effective. On the battle front or in besieged cities against civilian population.
I had a teenage crush on Lindsey!
Mr Roberts. As an in my early 20s person with a total shitshow life I was IN LOVE WITH HER ,totally. And I still think she is one of those few people at the top of evolution. But my love was in no way Lezzie. I hate how since from the 1960s the word love has got inextricably entangled with the word and concept of sex. Contrived thus of course. I think you can passionately love a person but it doesn't entail…oh well it's a deep hole I'm sure you know what I mean. This lady always seemed to me MORE than an actor,like a MEANINGFUL PERSON . And I know she left acting and went into teaching and human rights. I dont know if she is still with us but I think she was a fine person.
Hope for the best...but plan for the worst.
Yes. I hear speculation on how a blip on our device can kill us. I was puzzled at first. But as you say,it's the command the blip can send to shut down an operating system that will do it.
Your posts always teach me something David, as learning is so important to my every day existence. Sometimes though, I feel so uneducated and / or ignorant reading them (entirely not your fault BTW)!!
Reading this one through attracted me as I was eager to understand who exactly was the AI company that my husband had vaguely heard about overnight on his constant BBC World Service radio stream into his half awake ears and mind and as I don't watch the News. And then to hear your views. But you sadly lost me in the second sentence with "IPO" which Safari helped me with. (Good job telling me what ANT was!! :) and thank you as always for the great footnotes.
When I used to lecture in engineering or speak at conferences, I was always told not use acronyms or initialisms unless I explained them first. I was shocked that even though we were very minor 'traders' in stocks and shares back in the day; I had never heard of IPO but had clearly participated in them many times. Then you termed yourself as 'OG' further on and I assumed 'Old Guy'? Sorry. 🫣 Safari though, said it stands for "original gangster", or someone or something that is an originator, authentic, or highly respected for experience and seniority. I will remember you as this now.
As always, I go off track and have to say I think this piece is really interesting, very informative and certainly valuable for those hearing this on the News, or not! And.......I agree with your first internet search that you listed, what are the rules in the UK indeed?! And I love that you watch Blue Lights too!!
Thanks Sally. I should have spelled out the acronym for IPO, although I’m not sure I’d ever style myself as a “gangster!” So I hid behind that acronym.
I'm a UK citizen who lives here and most of us are asking what the rules are now,if there are any. We just get our Prime Ministers appointed,by each other and our King is off with the fairies
I to am a UK citizen Jane but now living in Spain and wondering what’s going on from afar and when you have children and grandchildren back there it can all be very disconcerting. That’s if we take any notice of what the media says too!!
I watched the SNL sketch twice and just could not stop laughing. So dry. Many thanks for making my day. Also thank you for sharing your thoughts on AI.
Molly, that was the second sketch. The first one may be even funnier but it doesn’t have the line about making it up through volume.
The best SNL cast!
You sound like my husband, less worried about AI than me. My husband’s portfolio is probably majority tech while mine is more diverse. I’m kind of on the fence about AI being oversaturated and becoming the next dot com. Yet I still bought a small number of ANT on its debut day.
Cynthia, it will be fascinating to watch it unfold. Public opinion is so negative on AI companies that any serious damage to people, e.g., an AI turning off electricity in the winter, will bring about huge political repercussions to these companies. So, I see politics as a tripwire.
That's what it's been invented for.
Someone had to be program AI to do things like that. It’s not something AI can do without an actual human feeding it instructions first!!
I do feel encouraged that you do not fear AI will render humans obsolete and jobless. Or that AI will be able to create artificial birth babies that grow up into fautless adults that perfectly impersonate perfect humans who gradually replace imperfect humans who are alive and would retain the living volition and agency that the AI babies wouldn't have until programmed with. Existence will finally become orderly because there will be no more variables leading to either bad manners or nuclear war. I stlll don't understand how all the negative possibilities of AI can be avoided. But if you believe they can or that they won't render humans extinct, that is comforting. Anything you might add concerning this would be great to read. But I think you must have good reasons for not being worried.
I wrote this to another comment:
Public opinion is so negative on AI companies that any serious damage to people, e.g., an AI turning off electricity in the winter, will bring about huge political repercussions to these companies. So, I see politics as a tripwire.
Like they care if we hurt or what we think.
Hopefully negative possibilities will be blocked before damage is done. 🙏🏻
This is a good, measured view. My industry is being a bit too precious about it, but internally, some big publishers are using AI — and so much is already AI-powered (like metadata). Then there are publishers who will let AI-assisted writing slide because they know the book will sell.
It's not good to be an absolutist about AI, because it is here to stay.
Thanks Kathleen. There are some published books that should have been written by AI. I’m looking at you, ghostwriter for The Tell!
YES
CNBC and other outlets suggested for days that the IPO was going to be a "clearing event." That is an event that will send, hopefully, a positive signal about the financial market's ability to efficiently allocate capital. I suspect the outlets were simply trying to appeal to the average investor's desire to see the market less as a casino but more as a efficient price discovery mechanism. Your piece nicely points out how various forces, most notably uncertainty, are driving trading and how the term "clearing event" was a bit misused. Again, thanks for the thoughtful piece.
I remember that SNL sketch 😂😂
Great point about Anthropic showing up in ETFs so more people can enjoy the benefit. 🙏🏻
When hubby told me about all the instant millionaires who work at Anthropic I was thrilled for them.
Finally, I love the story about Ashton Kutcher and Mila Kunis. Mila did not like him investing in Uber, which made him a fortune. Then she didn’t want him to invest $400 million into Anthropic. Now they’re worth 7 billion and Mila should stick to acting. 😂😂
The Proust query in your list made me smile, because that is exactly the sort of question I would never trust my own memory on and would still feel faintly guilty asking a machine. The revenues point lands too. A company can be growing fast and still be a long way from the part that matters, which is whether the money stays after the bills are paid. Do you think the market is mostly pricing the hope that the bills shrink, or that the revenue keeps compounding faster than anyone expects?
I think it is fear of missing out on what could turn into the most valuable company ever. Of course so many things have to go right for that to happen. The hype is huge but that doesn't mean it isn't right.
I don't understand ANY OF THIS which of course is why I'm who I am with my life. I'm not so upbeat as yourself Mr Roberts of the potential benefits of AI but yes,I dont think it's the dire threat to human life it's painted as either. It's notable that the people who are TALKING IT UP as dangerous,formidable,scary etc are the very people supposedly making it and selling it ,they obviously know or have been advised that making something sound dark and dangerous and forbidding (or even forbidden) is a winning sales pitch. - see I do know some stuff! Our Mrs Thatcher broke union power by selling off our industries and facilities. Her idea was that everyone should buy a few shares in phones,water,gas etc but it doesnt work like that as you know Mr Roberts. Everyone owning say,ten shares in the local water company and hiding them under the mattress for 30 years will result in worthless bits of paper nibbled by mice! Lots of people bought those 10 shares then sold them within hours for a huge profit to the big investors and everyone had http://to.do it pronto as by next day the market had collapsed. So in about 24 hours the nationalised industries and companies went from the peoples hands straight back into monolithic ownership. Good or Bad I don't know really. Water comes out of my taps and trains get me places. I don't really care otherwise.
Hi David, I read the same article in the WSJ and had to read the part about revenue growth twice since the writer referenced revenue growth as a positive indicator for Anthropic without considering future earnings potential or lack thereof. I thought I had misread that section of the article the first time. I really enjoyed your piece today. Hope all is well.
Thanks Joe. You and I are old fashioned in wanting earnings, cash flow, etc.
What a concept!
Two things. First, most people forget that, for many years, Amazon lost money and still loses money in the book business. But investors bought in at ridiculous levels on the prospect of future growth and earnings in other segments. In this case, their vision was rewarded, although in others, their futures bets went bust. Kind of like horse race handicapping...
As to AI, the sad truth is that no one has any real idea of the societal impact because this is most profound technological change in human history...makes printing with moveable type seem insignificant. Given short shrift is the very real potential of AI, especially when combined with robotics, to displace huge segments of the working population, leaving them little recourse to find other employment. In addition, we humans keep poisoning our environment, irrelevant to robots, which need neither food, water, nor clean air. It is thus not impossible that at some point in the not too distant future, computers might say to humans, "What do we need you for?" (I actually wrote that in a novel published thirty years ago.)
It seems that our only alternative is to move more slowly and more carefully, building in the sort of checks and controls that renders doomsday scenarios moot. But hey. that might have knocked Anthropic's market value down to $1 trillion. Oh, the horror.
I think the politics have turned so negative against the AI companies that any mishap that causes real damage to people will set off a political tripwire. And I think that a mishap is likely to occur before a robotic-led extermination. I’m thinking of something like a disruption to power.
We should be so lucky...
Haha not wealthy but have a small little account I play with. Bought a few shares of ANT.
"Sam’s trip to Vermont to visit a cult posing as a monastery. The cult claims to be creating a solution to the evils of AI through recording their quiet meditations and prayers."
More proof, if any were needed, that the well of human absurdity will never run dry.
LLMs remind me of the old Judaic Tanaaim—the professional memorizers. They never forget a detail about Proust.
From Google AI: Living Tape Recorders: Because Jewish law prohibited writing down the Oral Torah at the time, these men served as a living archive. They possessed exceptional mnemonic skills and committed massive volumes of rabbinic legal traditions (Mishnayot and Baraitot) to memory.
Thanks Kathleen
Never knew about the Tanaaim. Makes sense!
The New Yorker article is really well done and funny.